Railroaders place to shoot the shit.

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Nagging wife no longer a good defense


500 - Internal Server Error

Status: Offline
Posts: 36509
Date:
Nagging wife no longer a good defense
Permalink  
 


nagging-wife-curlers.gif

Husbands who kill wives can no longer claim they were provoked

Husbands who kill nagging wives will no longer be able to claim they were provoked, under a radical shake-up of the murder laws.

Suspects will also be prevented from pleading not guilty to murder by claiming it was a "crime of passion" because their partner was having an affair.

The reforms are designed to ensure domestic violence is treated as other forms of homicide.

As a result of the changes, battered wives who kill their abusers will be able to defend themselves against a murder charge by claiming diminished responsibility.

Following several years of consultation, the Government will next week announce the end of the "crime of passion" defence of provocation used by virtually all male defendants pleading not guilty to murder of a female partner.

Around 100 men a year kill their former or current partners, and provocation - such as failing to cook a meal, or persistent nagging - is the main form of defence used by barristers.

Relatives have complained that they have found it upsetting when murder suspects invoke lurid allegations about the victims' private lives.

In contrast, it is comparatively difficult for lawyers representing the 30 women a year on average who kill their partners to argue that they were provoked, as the crime tends not to take place in the heat of the moment, but is typically pre-planned.

While provocation is likely to remain on the statute book as a defence, it will be limited to the most serious instances, and will not include adultery or nagging.

The reforms are based on a 2006 review of the homicide laws by the Law Commission, and are backed by groups ranging from the Association of Chief Police Officers to Justice for Women.

At the time, the Commissioners complained that the murder laws were "a mess" and said that while appeal judges often did in practice free battered women who killed their abusive partners, this was not available as a straightforward defence in the first place.

One of the Commissioners, Prof Jeremy Holder, told The Telegraph: "The provocation laws have been a constant source of problems for the courts. To a large extent, there is a desire to be more lenient in the sympathetic cases, such as battered women, but the courts lack the laws to address this."

The proposed changes were welcomed by women's groups and law reformers.

A spokesman for Justice for Women said: "We welcome a change in the law. The women we deal with kill in desperation after suffering broken limbs, rape and constant fear. In contrast, at the moment men can get off a murder charge just because their wife is considered a nag."

Emma Scott, spokesman for Rights of Women, said: "Rights of Women has long had grave concerns that the current law continues to discriminate against women who kill and that the defence of provocation in particular is entirely inadequate in dealing with these situations."

In 1997, Joseph Swinburne was sentenced to 200 hours community service after he stabbed his wife 11 times when she told him she was leaving him for another man.

Kiranjit Ahluwalia was jailed for life for killing her violent husband in 1989 by setting his feet on fire following years of abuse. She was freed on appeal three years later, and her story made into a film.

The changes will also make it easier to prosecute gang members who join in an attack which results in murder, even if they did not wield the knife themselves.



__________________

© Equal Opportunity Annoyer

Troll The Anti-Fast Freight Freddie

 

 

 

 



Unstable & Irrational

Status: Online
Posts: 10778
Date:
Permalink  
 

Myself, I would just stand up and plead guiilty. No pretrial hearings or any of that crap.

__________________

I started ophph with nuthin, and I can safely say I have most of it left....
<img



Purveyor of Positive Attitudes

Status: Offline
Posts: 2839
Date:
Permalink  
 

I used to love her,
But I had to kill her.

__________________

Some people say I have a bad attitude. Those people are stupid.



Professional Asshole

Status: Offline
Posts: 5566
Date:
Permalink  
 

BlackDog wrote:

I used to love her,
But I had to kill her.



So I put her, 6 feet under,
and I can still hear her complain...

 



__________________





paypal.jpg



Upgraded Condition?

Status: Offline
Posts: 9211
Date:
Permalink  
 


http://youtube.com/watch?v=oEjKImNqBtM


I'm tired Lord and I'm drawn
And I'm chilled right to the bone
I crawled home from my work
And this note said she was gone
Said your dinner's in the cat
And your love is out the door
I'm goin' back to my momma
And I don't want you no more, no more
She said she don't want me no more
She's gone back to her momma
Said she's never never comin' back no more
Now a man can take so much
And only heaven knows his limit
But a naggin' bitchin' woman
Digs a hole and puts him in it
A sophisticated man
Needs a little something on the side
So what you don't get at home
You've gotta get outside, hey
She's gone
I'm spending all of my money
She's gone, gone, gone
And I can swing with my honey
She's gone
I'm so glad my woman's gone
Now time goes marching on
And it won't wait for you
You've gotta take it when it's offered
And get it when it's due
Now a man can move much faster
Without a millstone around his neck
So if you get the chance to lose it
You've gotta drop it and run like heck, hey

She's gone
I'm spending all of my money
She's gone, gone, gone
And I can swing with my honey
She's gone
I'm so glad my woman's gone
She's gone
I'm spending all of my money
She's gone, gone, gone
And I can swing with my honey
She's gone
I'm so glad my woman's gone



-- Edited by Calvin at 10:55, 2008-07-24

__________________

 This is the official end of my post.  



Professional Asshole

Status: Offline
Posts: 5566
Date:
Permalink  
 

Even the Bible makes reference to it...

A worthy wife is the crown of her husband, but a disgraceful one is like rot in his bones.
-- Proverbs 12:4

__________________





paypal.jpg



500 - Internal Server Error

Status: Offline
Posts: 36509
Date:
Permalink  
 

Ok......who is the smart ass?

DramaQueen
Full Name DramaQueen
Gender F
Location Nuttersville
Birthday 3:00 AM, 01/01/71
Country Name
Messages Posted 108
Status Active
Member Since 2:28 AM, 03/13/07
Last Access 9:47 PM, 05/15/08
Private Messaging Send Message
Critical But Stable
earth.gifearth.gif
avatar.img?ID=128301


__________________

© Equal Opportunity Annoyer

Troll The Anti-Fast Freight Freddie

 

 

 

 



Professional Asshole

Status: Offline
Posts: 5566
Date:
Permalink  
 

I don't get it...

__________________





paypal.jpg

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Chatbox
Please log in to join the chat!